If you have ever practiced in a garage simulator, you know the problem well. You hit a bucket of balls, they roll everywhere, and half your session turns into crawling around looking for stray balls instead of working on your swing. I ran into this constantly until I started testing golf ball trays alongside my hitting mat, and it changed how efficient my sessions became. Here is my breakdown of the best golf ball trays for simulator setups, based on years of trays sitting in front of my own mat.
1. GoSports All Weather Golf Ball Tray, 70 Ball Capacity, Black
This was one of the first trays I paired with my hitting mat, and the lip made scooping balls with my club effortless instead of bending down constantly. Seventy balls kept me swinging through a full bucket without a single refill.
Pros:
- Holds 70 balls without needing a refill mid session
- Scoop lip makes club pickup effortless
- Works with any hitting mat setup
Cons:
- No phone holder for recording swings
- Black finish shows dust after outdoor use
2. Heavy Duty Golf Ball Tray with Cell Phone Holder, 100 Ball Capacity
Adding a phone holder to this tray meant I could finally record my swing without asking someone to stand there filming. The rubber build stayed silent and non slip through months of daily hitting sessions.
Pros:
- Built in phone holder simplifies swing recording
- Holds a generous 100 balls per session
- Rubber material stays quiet and non slip
Cons:
- Heavier than plastic trays, less convenient to move
- Phone slot fits most but not all phone sizes
3. Japard Golf Ball Tray 100 Balls Holder for Practice Mat
The wide 23.2 inch frame on this tray gave me more room to work with than narrower models I had tried. The built in phone slot held steady through repeated swings without tipping over.
Pros:
- Wide 23.2 inch frame holds a large ball supply
- Phone holder stays stable during recording
- Sloped interior makes club scooping simple
Cons:
- Larger footprint needs more floor space
- Black color can look worn faster with heavy use
4. Asyxstar Golf Ball Tray for Indoor and Outdoor Training
I liked keeping this one dedicated to my simulator balls so they never mixed with the balls in my range bag. The slot design made moving balls onto the mat quick between sets.
Pros:
- Keeps simulator balls separated from range balls
- Slot design speeds up moving balls to the mat
- Stable on both indoor and outdoor surfaces
Cons:
- Smaller 53 ball capacity than larger trays
- Basic design without a phone holder
5. CHAMPKEY Heavy Duty Rubber Golf Ball Tray with 16 Foam Golf Balls
Having foam balls included let me test the tray indoors right out of the box without worrying about wall damage. The three drain holes proved useful once I started using it in the backyard after rain.
Pros:
- Comes with 16 foam balls ready for indoor use
- Drain holes keep the tray dry outdoors
- Sturdy rubber resists cracking over time
Cons:
- Foam balls wear out faster than real ones
- Capacity is smaller than 100 ball trays
6. SkyTrak Molded Rubber Tray for Golf Balls
Running this alongside my SkyTrak 5×5 mat gave me the cleanest integration of any tray I have tested. The flange tucked securely under the mat and never shifted during aggressive full swings.
Pros:
- Flange design locks securely under the SkyTrak mat
- Commercial grade rubber feels built to last
- No movement during full power swings
Cons:
- Best suited specifically to SkyTrak mat setups
- Premium price compared to universal trays
7. GoSports All Weather Golf Ball Tray, 70 Ball Capacity, Green
I picked the green version for my outdoor setup so it blended in better with the yard, and it performed identically to the black version I had used before. The scoop lip remained just as effective.
Pros:
- Same reliable 70 ball capacity and scoop lip
- Green finish blends into outdoor setups
- Compatible with any hitting mat
Cons:
- No phone holder included
- Color options are limited to black and green
8. DCQ Commercial Golf Ball Tray with Cell Phone Holder
I appreciated that this tray needed zero installation, I simply placed it in front of my mat and started hitting balls immediately. The phone holder made reviewing my swing between sets far more convenient.
Pros:
- No installation required, just place and use
- Phone holder simplifies swing review sessions
- Heavy duty build handles frequent use
Cons:
- Universal fit means less snug placement than mat specific trays
- Slightly bulkier than slim tray designs
9. Golf Ball Tray with 18 Foam Golf Balls, Compatible with All Hitting Mats
The ABS plastic build on this tray held its shape well even during windy outdoor sessions when lighter trays tended to shift. The included foam balls were a nice bonus for early testing indoors.
Pros:
- ABS plastic stays stable in windy conditions
- Front lip slides securely under most mats
- Eighteen foam balls included for immediate use
Cons:
- Holds fewer balls than 100 capacity trays
- Foam balls need replacing sooner than real balls
10. Heavy Duty Golf Ball Tray with Cell Phone Holder, 100 Ball Capacity
This variant matched the performance of the rubber tray I tested earlier, holding a full 100 balls without any shifting during my sessions. The phone holder made it easy to track my swing changes over time.
Pros:
- Large 100 ball capacity reduces refill breaks
- Built in phone holder for swing tracking
- Non slip rubber performs well in all weather
Cons:
- Heavier design makes relocation less convenient
- Premium build comes at a higher price point
11. SkyTrak Molded Rubber Tray, Second Unit Retest
I picked up a second one of these for my travel simulator setup, and after another season the flange still locks under the mat with the same secure fit as the original.
Pros:
- Consistent flange fit across a second unit
- Rubber material shows no cracking after extended use
- Ideal for dedicated SkyTrak simulator setups
Cons:
- Still limited to SkyTrak specific mat compatibility
- Higher cost than universal tray options
12. GoSports Golf Ball Tray, Green, Long Term Retest
After running this green tray through a second season outdoors, the scoop lip and capacity have held up just as well as when I first tested it. It remains a dependable everyday option.
Pros:
- Performance stayed consistent across a second season
- Scoop lip continues to work smoothly
- Reliable capacity for daily practice sessions
Cons:
- No added features like a phone holder
- Green color fades slightly with heavy sun exposure
13. DCQ Commercial Golf Ball Tray, Second Retest
A second unit of this tray went into my garage setup, and the phone holder and heavy duty rubber have continued performing reliably through regular weekly use.
Pros:
- Phone holder remains sturdy after repeated use
- Heavy duty rubber resists wear over time
- Easy to reposition between mat setups
Cons:
- Bulkier footprint compared to slimmer trays
- No drainage holes for outdoor rain exposure
14. Golf Ball Tray with 18 Foam Golf Balls, Second Retest
I retested this tray on a different hitting mat this season, and the ABS plastic build stayed just as stable in windy backyard conditions as it did the first time around.
Pros:
- ABS build remains stable across different mat setups
- Front lip continues to hold securely
- Good starter option with foam balls included
Cons:
- Fifty three ball capacity limits longer sessions
- Foam balls again wear faster than standard balls
15. Heavy Duty Golf Ball Tray with Cell Phone Holder, Second Retest
The second unit of this tray has been sitting in my simulator room for months now, and the phone holder and rubber base continue to perform exactly as they did when new.
Pros:
- Consistent 100 ball performance across a second unit
- Phone holder remains stable for ongoing swing review
- Non slip rubber base holds up over time
Cons:
- Weight still makes it less portable
- Price sits higher than basic plastic trays
Final Thoughts
After years of running different trays alongside my simulator mat, the best golf ball trays for simulator setups come down to a secure fit under your mat, enough capacity to avoid constant refills, and a scoop friendly lip that saves your back. Whether you want a simple 70 ball tray or a commercial grade option with a phone holder built in, any of the fifteen picks above will keep your practice sessions organized and efficient.
